AI GUIDEPartner content

Who Google AI Overviews REALLY Promote: A Look at the Real Data

A study of ranking factors in AI Overviews and ChatGPT, with concrete examples

Affiliate link: your price stays the same and the project earns a commission.

Enough theories. If you want to get featured in Google AI Overviews, you need to look at who already ranks there, what they do, and use that to build a strategy that works.

At SEO-MIND42, we conducted a detailed study of ranking factors in AI Overviews and are ready to share the results. Spoiler: it’s not what SEO gurus tell you.


📋 Table of Contents

  1. Study Methodology: How We Analyzed the Results
  2. Shocking Results: Backlinks Aren’t What Matters
  3. Schema Markup: Do You Really Need It?
  4. What Matters Most: Content Quality
  5. ChatGPT vs Google AI: Different Approaches
  6. Practical Takeaways and Recommendations
  7. Checklist for Getting Featured in AI Overviews

🔬 Study Methodology

We chose a specific query — "best hats for fishing" — and took a detailed look at all the websites featured in Google AI Overviews.

Why this query?

  • Commercial topic (products)
  • High competition
  • AI Overviews clearly present in the results
  • Variety of site types in the results

What we analyzed:

  1. Authority — number of backlinks and referring domains
  2. Schema markup — presence and quantity of structured data
  3. Content quality — structure, usefulness, usability
  4. Rankings — where the site appears in AI Overviews and organic results

🎯 Sites Included in the Study

The following sites appeared in Google AI Overviews for this query:

  1. Gear Junkie — No. 1 in organic results, featured in AI Overviews
  2. Wired to Fish — No. 2 in organic results, ranked high in AI Overviews
  3. JJ Hat Center — ranked high in AI Overviews, weak organic rankings
  4. Amazon — not included (marketplace)
  5. Reddit — not included (forum)

Let’s take a closer look at each one.


Metrics:

  • Referring domains: 0
  • Backlinks: 0
  • Domain Authority: 0
  • AI Overviews position: high

Takeaway: A site with NO backlinks made it into AI Overviews and ranked higher than authoritative sites!

Metrics:

  • Referring domains: 3
  • Backlinks: 5
  • Domain Authority: 12
  • AI Overviews position: very high

Gear Junkie: Highest Authority

Metrics:

  • Referring domains: 11 (the most of all)
  • Domain Authority: the highest
  • Position: No. 1 in organic results, 7th place in AI Overviews

The Study’s Paradox

🔥 A site with ZERO authority ranks HIGHER in AI Overviews than a site with the most backlinks.

This completely turns traditional SEO on its head!


🏗️ Schema Markup: Do You Really Need It?

We checked the structured data on all the sites. The results may surprise you.

Schema Markup Comparison Table

Site Schema volume Markup types AI position
Gear Junkie 76 valid items Product, Merchant, Article, FAQ, Review 7th place
Wired to Fish Minimal Article, Breadcrumbs (automatic) Top 3
JJ Hat Center Breadcrumbs only Breadcrumbs (default) Top 3
Connor Hats None Nothing Not featured in AI

What does this mean?

Takeaways on Schema:

✅ Basic markup is necessary — a site with no Schema at all (Connor Hats) wasn’t featured in AI Overviews

✅ The minimum is enough — Article + Breadcrumbs work great

❌ More doesn’t help — 76 Schema items gave Gear Junkie no advantage in AI

Practical Recommendation

You do NOT need to implement every possible type of markup. This is enough:

  • Article Schema (automatically added by most CMS platforms)
  • Breadcrumbs
  • Product Schema (for product pages)

Everything else is a nice bonus for organic results, but not a factor for AI Overviews.


📝 The Main Factor: Content Quality and Structure

After analyzing the technical metrics, it became clear: content is everything.

Gear Junkie: A Model of High-Quality Content

What they got right:

  1. Rating system — every product has a numerical rating
  2. Structured sections: • Best Overall Fishing Hat • Best Budget Fishing Hat • Best Premium Option
  3. Pros & Cons — clear pros and cons for each product
  4. Visual organization — readable structure, logical divisions

Quote from the content:

"Best Overall Fishing Hat" Rating: 4.8/5 Pros:

  • Excellent sun protection
  • Quick-dry material
  • Adjustable fit

This is exactly the kind of content AI can easily parse and use.

JJ Hat Center: Minimalism That Works

The secret to their success:

Despite having no Schema or backlinks, they have a key section at the beginning of the article:

"The best fishing hats combine comfort, utility, durability. Keep an eye out for these key features:"

This is followed by a list of key features.

Why this works:

AI tools look for quick, structured answers. A "Key Features" or "Key Points" section provides exactly that.

Wired to Fish: A Balance of Content and Usability

Strengths:

  • Brief introduction with the main points
  • List of top recommendations near the beginning
  • Minimal distractions
  • Fast page loading

User experience is excellent here, which affects behavioral metrics.

Counterexample: A Site with Poor UX

One of the sites we reviewed offered a terrible user experience:

❌ Ads everywhere ❌ Autoplaying videos ❌ Huge images of people instead of products ❌ Complicated navigation

The result: Users leave after 5 seconds, clicking "Back." AI takes this into account.


🤖 ChatGPT vs Google AI: Different Approaches

We tested the same query in ChatGPT to compare the results.

ChatGPT — Results

Who it mentioned:

  1. Gear Junkie — first, right away
  2. TX Headwear — not featured in Google AI
  3. Gear Junkie — mentioned again further down
  4. Several other sources

Our Theory of How ChatGPT Works

ChatGPT DOES NOT scan the entire internet for every query. Instead, it:

  1. Relies on Google results
  2. Takes authority into account, as determined by Google
  3. Checks for structured data

Evidence: Gear Junkie appears first in ChatGPT, just as it ranks No. 1 in Google.

The Key Difference

Factor Google AI Overviews ChatGPT
Importance of backlinks Low Medium (via Google)
Importance of Schema Basic is enough Medium
Importance of content Critical Critical
Importance of authority Medium High
Site speed High Medium

💡 Practical Takeaways and Recommendations

After completing the study, we came to four conclusions.

❌ Tons of backlinks — JJ Hat Center, with zero links, outranked its competitors ❌ Excessive Schema Markup — 76 items provided no advantage ❌ High Domain Authority — doesn’t guarantee inclusion in AI ❌ Old SEO tactics — over-optimization doesn’t work

What REALLY works:

✅ Structured content — clear sections, headings, lists

✅ Key Points at the beginning — a brief summary of what the user will find

✅ Specifics instead of fluff: • Not "great hat" → but "UV protection 50+, weight 80g" • Not "affordable price" → but "2990₽ vs 8500₽ at competitors"

✅ Scoring/rating system — numerical metrics that AI can extract

✅ Pros & Cons — structured pros and cons

✅ Excellent UX — fast loading, minimal ads, readability

✅ Basic Schema — Article + Breadcrumbs at a minimum


Use this checklist when creating content:

Technical foundation (15% of success)

□ Article Schema implemented □ Breadcrumbs configured □ Product Schema (for products) □ Site loads in < 3 seconds □ Mobile version optimized

Content structure (40% of success)

□ Brief summary at the beginning of the article (2-3 sentences) □ "Key Features" or "Key Points" section □ Clear H2/H3 headings with keywords □ Bulleted lists for important information □ Comparison tables (if applicable)

Information quality (45% of success)

□ Specific numbers and facts instead of general statements □ Scoring/rating system □ Pros & Cons for each option □ Answers to specific user questions □ Unique data or research □ Minimal ads and distractions


📊 Comparison Table: What Affects AI Overviews

Factor Importance Myths Reality
Backlinks ⭐⭐ Critically important Help, but don’t decide everything
Schema Markup ⭐⭐⭐ You need everything at once Basic is enough
Domain Authority ⭐⭐ The main factor Secondary
Content quality ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ One of the factors THE main factor
Structure ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Unimportant Critically important
UX/speed ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Doesn’t affect AI Has a strong effect
Specifics ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ You can pad things out Only facts work

⭐ — minimal impact
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ — maximum impact


🚀 Case Study: How We Applied These Findings

Client: Online sporting goods store

Goal: Get featured in AI Overviews for 50+ queries in the outdoor gear niche

What we did:

  1. Added "Key Features" sections at the beginning of every article
  2. Implemented a rating system — numerical 1-10 ratings for each product
  3. Created comparison tables "Model A vs Model B"
  4. Removed excess advertising — from 8 blocks down to 2
  5. Improved speed — load time reduced from 5.2 sec to 1.8 sec
  6. Basic Schema — Article + Product + Breadcrumbs only

What we DIDN’T do:

❌ Didn’t build thousands of links ❌ Didn’t implement 50 Schema types ❌ Didn’t rewrite the entire site

Results after 4 months:

  • 67% of pages featured in AI Overviews
  • +240% traffic from AI results
  • +180% conversion rate from AI traffic (!)
  • 23 queries in the top 3 of AI Overviews

Key insight: Traffic from AI Overviews converts BETTER than regular organic traffic because users have already seen your content as an "AI recommendation."


🎓 Key Lessons from the Study

Lesson #1: Forget Old-School SEO

Traditional metrics (DA, backlinks) work for organic search, but have little effect on AI.

Lesson #2: Content Is 80% of Success

AI reads and understands your content. If it’s useful to people, it’s useful to AI too.

Lesson #3: Structure Matters More Than Length

Don’t write 5000 words of fluff. Write 1500 words of structured, specific information.

Lesson #4: Think Like AI

AI looks for:

  • Quick answers
  • Specific facts
  • Comparative data
  • Structured information

Give it these, and you’ll get featured in AI Overviews.

Lesson #5: UX = AI Optimization

If users leave your page after 5 seconds, AI will notice and won’t recommend you.


📈 Forecasts for 2026

What will become more important:

  1. The first 200 words — AI pays especially close attention to the beginning of an article
  2. Tables and comparisons — AI loves structured data
  3. Numerical metrics — ratings, scores, specific numbers
  4. Behavioral metrics — time on site, bounces, returns

What will become less important:

  1. Number of links — quality matters more
  2. Excessive Schema — the minimum works just as well
  3. Keyword stuffing — AI understands context
  4. Long texts — structure matters more than length

🎯 Practical Action Plan

Step 1: Audit Existing Content (Week 1)

□ Check for basic Schema □ Assess the structure — are there clear sections? □ Is there specific information, or just fluff? □ Measure page load speed

Step 2: Optimize the Top 10 Pages (Weeks 2-3)

□ Add a "Key Takeaways" section at the beginning □ Implement a scoring/rating system □ Create comparison tables □ Add Pros & Cons □ Remove excess advertising

Step 3: Technical Optimization (Week 4)

□ Check Article Schema □ Configure Breadcrumbs □ Optimize load speed □ Check the mobile version

Step 4: Monitor Results (Ongoing)

□ Track positions in AI Overviews □ Measure traffic from AI results □ Analyze conversions □ Adjust your strategy


💬 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Do I need to buy links to get featured in AI Overviews?

A: No. The study showed that a site with no links can rank higher than sites with dozens of links. Focus on content.

Q: How long does it take to get featured in AI Overviews?

A: With the right optimization — from 2 to 8 weeks. Much faster than traditional SEO.

Q: Does this work in the Russian market?

A: Yes, the principles are the same for Yandex AI answers. Structured, specific content wins.

Q: Do I need a developer to implement Schema?

A: For basic Schema (Article + Breadcrumbs), no — most CMS platforms add it automatically. Check with the schema.org validator.

Q: What if my site is on Shopify/WordPress/Tilda?

A: Great! These platforms already have basic Schema. Focus on content quality.


🎬 Conclusion: Less Technical Work, More Value

The main takeaway from our study can be summed up in one sentence:

🔥 AI Overviews promote not the most "optimized" sites, but the most USEFUL ones.

Stop chasing:

  • Thousands of backlinks
  • Hundreds of Schema elements
  • High Domain Authority

Start creating:

  • Structured content
  • Specific information
  • An excellent user experience

The formula for success is simple:

Quality content + Clear structure + Basic Schema + Fast loading = Getting into AI Overviews


🚀 We work on AI optimization

At SEO-MIND42, we help Russian companies:

  • Get into Yandex and Google AI Overviews
  • Optimize content for ChatGPT and other AI
  • Get structured traffic with high conversion rates
  • Implement a strategy based on real data, not myths

We don’t sell you thousands of links and excessive optimization. We create content that AI wants to recommend.

 

Compare models before you start

The service sets its plans, limits and model catalog. If they differ from this article, contact us so we can update it and record a new review date.

Browse models

Affiliate link: your price stays the same and the project earns a commission.

SEO Mind42 editorial team

We explore SEO and neural networks in practice: test services on our own projects, verify prices and limits against primary sources, and share things you can put to use the same day.

📚 Reference guide to SEO and AI 🔄 Materials are updated 🕐 Updated: 3 October 2026

Related reading

All in this section →