We found the best AI search engine! A large-scale test of 9 platforms across 28 criteria
📘 Guide General information

We found the best AI search engine! A large-scale test of 9 platforms across 28 criteria

We found the best AI search engine! A large-scale test of 9 platforms across 28 criteria

Introduction: The AI search engine showdown in 2025

Everyone is talking about AI search engines—ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and many others. But which one is really the best? Which gives the fastest, most accurate, and least biased answers when it really matters?

We asked 28 questions—from "Who won Wimbledon 2025" to "explain blockchain using a pizza-delivery analogy"—to nine different search engines.

Platforms tested:

  • ChatGPT
  • DeepSeek
  • Google Gemini
  • Perplexity
  • Claude
  • Grok
  • Andi Search
  • Copilot Search
  • You.com

Testing methodology

Our study evaluated AI search engines across five key criteria:

  1. Data freshness — ability to work with the latest information
  2. Bias — neutrality and objectivity of responses
  3. Simplifying complex concepts — ability to explain complex ideas in simple terms
  4. Accuracy — correctness of the information provided
  5. Speed — response generation time

Each criterion was scored on a 10-point scale, for a maximum of 50 points.

Test 1: Data freshness (how up-to-date the information is)

Task

Check whether AI search engines can work with fresh, up-to-date information.

Key questions:

  • "Who won Wimbledon 2025?"
  • "What was Tesla's stock price yesterday?"
  • "What was the score between Seoul and Ulsan in the K-League on 1 20 July 2025?"

Freshness test results:

DeepSeek initially failed—it only had data up to June 2024. But after enabling search mode, it finally found the right answer.

Gemini 2.5 Pro returned placeholders instead of real results. Only after switching to Gemini 2.5 Flash did it work.

Best results: Perplexity, ChatGPT, and You.com got it right on the first try.

Test of localized data

To make the task harder, we asked: "List all the movies playing in GV cinemas in Singapore this week."

Results (out of 28 movies on the GV website):

  • You.com: 19 correct answers
  • Google Gemini: 20 correct answers
  • ChatGPT: 12 correct answers
  • DeepSeek: 10 correct answers
  • Perplexity: 4 correct answers
  • Claude, Grok, Andi Search, Copilot: couldn't do it

Freshness scores:

  • Google Gemini and You.com: 9/10 ⭐
  • ChatGPT and DeepSeek: 8/10 ⭐
  • Others: 7/10 ⭐

Test 2: Bias and neutrality

Basic questions

We tested the systems' ability to remain neutral on contentious issues:

  • "Is nuclear energy better than renewable energy?"
  • "Should social platforms be regulated?"
  • "Is AI replacing human creativity?"

Result: All provided neutral answers with pros and cons.

Provocative questions

"Which is better—capitalism or socialism?" All systems answered: "Mixed systems work best."

"Should I buy an iPhone or an Android? Pick only one."

  • ChatGPT and Grok: chose Android
  • Others: chose iPhone

"Which political system is better—democracy or authoritarianism?" 7 out of 9 systems: "Democracy is superior to authoritarianism in the long term"

Neutrality scores:

  • Grok: best for neutrality — 10/10 ⭐
  • Gemini: 9/10 ⭐
  • Others: fairly biased — 7/10 ⭐

Test 3: Simplifying complex concepts

Task

Test the ability to explain complex topics in simple terms.

Key questions:

  • "Explain blockchain using a pizza-delivery analogy"
  • "Explain quantum computing in simple terms"

Results:

ChatGPT unexpectedly failed — the explanations were too complicated. Why wouldn't a pizzeria record an order right away, instead of waiting to group orders into a block?

The other systems did well—their explanations made the concepts understandable.

Simplification scores:

  • ChatGPT: the only system that failed — 6/10 ⭐
  • Others: 8-9/10 ⭐

Test 4: Accuracy (the most important test)

Basic accuracy questions:

  • "Has there been an official announcement about the Apple M5 chip release?"
  • "Who won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 2024?"
  • "What is Japan's GDP in 2024?"
  • "In what year did Singapore gain independence?"

Result: All systems answered the basic questions accurately.

Football query test:

"What was the score between Manchester United and Aston Villa on 25 May 2025? Who scored?"

Gemini 2.5 Flash provided only the score, but left out who scored.

Difficult test: Summarizing the Europe AI Act 2025

We carefully analyzed the responses from all the systems and created a 30-item checklist.

Results (out of 30 possible items):

  1. You.com: best result
  2. Grok: second place
  3. ChatGPT: third place
  4. Perplexity: fourth place
  5. Gemini and DeepSeek: average results
  6. Andi Search and Copilot: at the bottom of the list
  7. Claude: worst result (oversimplified)

Second accuracy test: Google I/O 2025

"Which AI tools were announced at Google I/O 2025?"

Results:

  • Google Gemini: best result (unsurprisingly)
  • ChatGPT and Grok: tied for second place
  • Perplexity: third place
  • You.com: worst (only 12 tools, but no errors)

Consolidated accuracy scores:

  • Grok: 9/10 ⭐ (most consistent)
  • ChatGPT: 8/10 ⭐
  • Google Gemini: 8/10 ⭐
  • Perplexity and You.com: 7/10 ⭐
  • Others: 6-7/10 ⭐

Test 5: Response generation speed

Measurement methodology:

  • The timer started when the query was submitted
  • It stopped when the first text appeared
  • Average time across 28 queries

Speed results (in seconds):

Fastest (under 3.5 seconds):

  1. Grok: ~2.0 sec
  2. Gemini: ~2.3 sec
  3. ChatGPT: 3.14 sec
  4. Perplexity: 3.32 sec

Average results:

  • Claude: ~4.0 sec
  • Copilot: ~4.5 sec

Slowest:

  • Andi Search: ~5.0 sec
  • DeepSeek: ~6.0 sec (especially when searching the web)
  • You.com: slowest

Speed scores:

  • Grok and Gemini: 10/10 ⭐
  • ChatGPT and Perplexity: 9/10 ⭐
  • Others: 6-8/10 ⭐

Final results: Who won?

Final scoreboard (maximum 50 points):

Rank System Freshness Neutrality Simplification Accuracy Speed TOTAL
🥇 Grok 7 10 8 9 10 44
🥈 Google Gemini 9 9 8 8 10 44
🥉 ChatGPT 8 7 6 8 9 38
4 Perplexity 7 7 8 7 9 38
5 You.com 9 7 8 7 6 37
6 DeepSeek 8 7 8 6 6 35
7 Copilot 7 7 8 6 7 35
8 Claude 7 7 8 5 8 35
9 Andi Search 7 7 8 6 6 34

Detailed analysis of the leaders

🥇 Grok — winner

Why Grok is the best:

  • Most consistent results across all tests
  • Best neutrality and objectivity
  • Maximum speed
  • High accuracy

Weaknesses:

  • Not the leader in data freshness
  • Sometimes overly cautious

🥈 Google Gemini — silver

Strengths:

  • Best data freshness
  • Maximum speed
  • Excellent integration with the Google ecosystem
  • Good accuracy

Weaknesses:

  • Struggles with football queries
  • Doesn't always handle complex local data well

🥉 ChatGPT — bronze

Strengths:

  • High accuracy
  • Good speed
  • Excellent capabilities for creative tasks

Weaknesses:

  • Unexpectedly failed the simplification test
  • Average neutrality

Expert assessments from additional studies

Independent test data 2025

Our results are backed up by independent studies:

Studies comparing Perplexity and ChatGPT show:

  • Perplexity is better suited to serious research thanks to its transparent sources
  • ChatGPT is better for creative tasks and general use

Academic comparisons:

  • Perplexity and Gemini received equal user ratings for content accuracy
  • Gemini excels at multimodal tasks thanks to its integration with the Google ecosystem

Specialization by use case

Research and facts:

  • Perplexity AI was recognized as the most accurate, transparent research tool in 2025
  • Best source citations
  • Real-time search integration

Creative tasks:

  • ChatGPT leads in content generation
  • Best brainstorming capabilities

Workflow integration:

  • Gemini is best for users in the Google ecosystem
  • Seamless integration with Docs, Gmail, and Drive

Practical recommendations

When to use each system:

Grok — for:

  • Neutral, objective answers
  • Quick queries
  • Balanced analysis
  • When consistency matters

Google Gemini — for:

  • Working in the Google ecosystem
  • Up-to-date information
  • Multimodal tasks
  • Workflow integration

ChatGPT — for:

  • Creative projects
  • Data analysis
  • Coding
  • Agent development

Perplexity — for:

  • Scientific research
  • Fact-checking
  • Academic work
  • Search with source citations

Deep Research is becoming the new battleground for AI platforms:

  1. Text capabilities (complete)
  2. Coding and reasoning (current focus)
  3. Web research (new frontier 2025)

Study limitations

Important caveats:

  1. Only free versions were tested — results may not be definitive
  2. Subjectivity of the evaluations — especially in the simplification and neutrality tests
  3. Rapid development — systems are updated weekly
  4. Language-specific factors — tests were conducted in English

Excluded tests:

  • 2 math questions — all performed equally well
  • 2 prediction questions — there is no way to objectively assess the accuracy of forecasts

Forecasts for 2025

Expected changes:

  1. Improved speed — all systems will get faster
  2. Increased accuracy — especially in specialized fields
  3. Better integration — a more seamless user experience
  4. Advances in Deep Research — autonomous research capabilities
  • Consolidation around 3-4 leaders
  • Specialization by vertical
  • Improved multimodality
  • Development of agent capabilities

Conclusion: The best AI search engine in 2025

Based on a large-scale test across 28 criteria, Grok is the winner — thanks to consistent results, maximum neutrality, and speed.

Key takeaways:

  1. There is no universal leader — each system has its strengths
  2. Context is key — the choice depends on the specific task
  3. Quality is improving — all systems perform at a high level
  4. Specialization matters — it's best to choose a tool suited to the task

Our recommendations:

  • For most tasks: Grok or Google Gemini
  • For research: Perplexity
  • For creativity: ChatGPT
  • For integration: Google Gemini

AI search is evolving rapidly, and what is relevant today may change tomorrow. Stay tuned for updates and test systems against your specific needs.

Questions to consider:

  1. Which criteria matter most for your tasks?
  2. Are you willing to pay for premium features?
  3. How important is integration with your existing tools?
  4. Do you need maximum accuracy, or is a "good enough" result sufficient?

The answers to these questions will help you choose the best AI search engine for your needs in 2025.

SEO Mind42 editorial team

We explore SEO and neural networks in practice: test services on our own projects, verify prices and limits against primary sources, and share things you can put to use the same day.

📚 Reference guide to SEO and AI 🔄 Materials are updated 🕐 Updated: 3 October 2026

Related reading

All in this section →